“Sale ends soon! Get your discount before it expires! We only have 30 minutes before I need to leave for the airport. Make your final offer!”
How many of us have heard or used similar phrases to create a sense of urgency in our negotiations? Knowingly or unknowingly, these phrases tap into our innate human desire to get something before it runs out.
This is another one of social psychologist and bestselling author Robert Cialdini’s powerful psychological principles underlying the negotiation process: the Scarcity Principle. In my Part One column on these timeless principles, I discussed his Liking and Tribalism Principles. Here are three more.
3. The Scarcity Principle
“How can we strengthen our leverage” is one of the most common questions I am asked in my training programs. Since leverage is fluid and changes depending on what you do and say and the moves you make, I often suggest that parties try to impact their counterpart’s perception of their Plan Bs (what your counterpart will do if they don’t do a deal with you).
If you can get your counterpart to focus on their relatively poor Plan B, this strengthens your leverage.
The Scarcity Principle underlies this notion. As Cialdini notes, people value things more if they are or perceive them to be scarce or in limited quantities (assuming your alternative/Plan B to getting that item is poor to nonexistent).
How does this play out in negotiations? Party A might emphasize the relatively unique elements of their item for sale or present the “scarce” opportunity as expiring within a certain timeframe (like Black Friday sales). These moves increase Party B’s psychological feeling that “I need to get it now or I will miss out (and thus go with my relatively poor Plan B). FOMO, right?
How should you incorporate this into your strategy? Recognize this tendency when your counterpart emphasizes an item’s scarcity and evaluate if your Plan B really is bad. There might be another sale next week or the deadline might be flexible!
4. Social Proof
Peer pressure can be powerful. If people around me believe X is valuable, I will be more inclined to believe it too. This is especially true if a) I respect those people, and b) the objective value of X is unclear and ambiguous based on other factors.
This is one reason auctions most often favor sellers (see my column on how to achieve your goals in auctions). If John bid $1,000 for that art piece, it must be worth at least that amount, right?
Recognizing and identifying this “social proof” psychological tendency is another of Cialdini’s important contributions to our field.
In negotiations, this is one element of my Third Golden Rule of Negotiation: Employ “Fair” Objective Criteria. After all, social proof is a relevant component of how we determine the “fair and reasonable” value of items on the table.
Of course, be wary of this principle too. Don’t just rely on others’ opinions. Do your own due diligence. John may value that art differently than you or anyone else. Peer pressure can also be destructive and expensive, especially if it’s not based on independent objective standards like market value, precedent, expert opinion, etc.
5. The Reciprocity Principle
We just returned from a family vacation to Türkiye and Greece. Among my many negotiations there, one stood out. Our tour guide in Türkiye took us to a nice Turkish rug store near the Blue Mosque for a break after our morning tour.
What happened? The manager first demonstrated how they make rugs and had our daughter weave a few strands. Then he sat us down on some comfortable chairs, brought us apple tea and some Turkish delight, and proceeded to further educate us about Turkish rugs by having his associates roll out about 25 different types and styles of rugs. They were beautiful. And he didn’t ask for anything in return!
It was a brilliant illustration of Cialdini’s Reciprocity Principle – the idea that people feel a strong psychological tendency to return favors, gifts, or concessions after receiving them. “It’s your turn, right?” Critically, this works even when you know it’s happening!
While we didn’t buy anything (the rugs were extremely expensive!), both my wife and I felt like we needed to give the manager something in return. So, I offered to send him a signed copy of my new book (which he accepted).
Another example of this principle includes lawyers and business professionals taking their clients or customers out for lunch, dinner or to sporting events and paying for them.
What are they communicating? You pay us thousands of dollars in fees, and we will occasionally take you out for dinner? No. The crucial element is the implicit message: you do something for me (hire me and pay my fees) and then I will do something for you in return. The critical element is not the amount of the exchange but that the reciprocal exchange takes place.
Latz’s Lesson: Cialdini’s Scarcity, Social Proof and Reciprocity Principles impact almost every negotiation. Understand them, use them, and beware of how they might be used against you too.
* Marty Latz is the founder of Latz Negotiation, a national negotiation training and consulting company that helps individuals and organizations achieve better results with best practices based on the experts’ research. He can be reached at 480.951.3222 or Marty@LatzNegotiation.com.